Shared Property: When One Owner Wants to Sell and the Other Refuses
Property co-ownership is quite common in South Africa, often driven by affordability challenges. While it can be a practical solution, disputes can quickly arise. In a recent discussion, our Director, Claire Laurent, unpacked the facts with Power98.7 host, Kwena Moabelo, about core ownership disputes, specifically what happens when two or more people jointly own a property and one party wants to sell while the other one refuses.
Listen to their full discussion here: PowerFM Radio Interview
In legal terms, co-ownership means that each party owns an undivided share in the whole property, not just a specific portion of it. Whether ownership is split equally or not, all co-owners have rights to the entire property.
The Supreme Court of Appeal confirms that no one can be forced to remain a co-owner against their will. This means that if one party wants to exit the arrangement, they are legally entitled to do so. The primary available solution is the actio communi dividundo, a long-standing Roman-Dutch action that allows a co-owner to apply to court to terminate the co-ownership relationship. The purpose of this solution is to ensure that co-owners are not indefinitely bound to an arrangement that has become unworkable, while still ensuring fairness to all parties involved.
Although a co-owner can sell their individual share without consent, this is rarely practical, as few buyers are willing to enter into a shared ownership arrangement with a stranger. As a result, disputes often escalate to the point where one party seeks to sell the entire property. If co-owners cannot agree, the court will step in to determine a just and equitable outcome based on the specific circumstances of the case. This may include ordering one party to buy out the other’s share, based on independent valuations. If neither party can afford to do so, the court may order that the property be sold, often by auction, and the proceeds divided according to each owner’s share.
In cases of marriage in community of property, these issues are typically dealt with under the Divorce Act 70 of 1979 as part of divorce proceedings, rather than through a separate co-ownership application.
To avoid these disputes, it is crucial to have a written co-ownership agreement in place from the outset. Such an agreement should cover ownership shares, financial responsibilities, maintenance, usage, and exit mechanisms, including what happens if one party wants to sell. A right of first refusal is also commonly included to give co-owners the opportunity to buy each other out before involving third parties.
While the law provides solutions, co-ownership disputes can be complex and costly. Proper planning and clear agreements remain the most effective way to protect all parties and avoid unnecessary conflict.
The 2026 CCMA Rule Changes
The 2026 CCMA Rule Changes: What Employers and Employees Need to Know The way workplace disputes are handled in South Africa is changing, and some of these changes may catch employers and employees by surprise. On 23 October 2026, new rules governing proceedings...
Early Cancellation of a Residential Lease: Landlord vs Tenant
Early Cancellation of a Residential Lease: Landlord vs Tenant By Cilna Steyn, Managing Director of SBL Incorporated Early cancellation of a residential lease is often misunderstood, particularly because the rights of a tenant and landlord are not the same. When the...
Neighbour Nightmares
Neighbour Nightmares: When Does an Annoying Neighbour Become a Legal Problem? Most of us expect our homes to be places of comfort, privacy and peace. Unfortunately, that's not always the reality. From persistent noise and barking dogs to boundary disputes, parking...



