Social media has become a powerful platform for communication, connection, and community engagement. However, when misused, especially within the context of managing community schemes, it can lead to serious legal consequences. The recent High Court ruling of Francois Jurie Nicolaas Harman v Pieter Hendrik Strydom (285/2024) ZASCA 108 on social media defamation is a timely reminder that freedom of expression has boundaries, particularly when it infringes on the rights and reputations of others.
In this article, we explore how easily property owners, tenants, trustees, and managing agents can fall into the trap of online defamation when attempting to expose alleged wrongdoing. Unfortunately, this often results in unintended legal trouble for the person posting.
Freedom of Expression and Its Limits in South Africa
All South Africans enjoy the right to freedom of expression under Section 16 of the Constitution. However, this right is not absolute. Section 16(2) explicitly excludes speech that amounts to incitement of violence, propaganda for war, or advocacy of hatred, especially when it constitutes hate speech.
The Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act (PEPUDA) further defines hate speech and protects individuals against unfair discrimination, including on public platforms.
In the context of social media, the line between expressing dissatisfaction and committing defamation can easily be crossed, often unintentionally.
What is Defamation?
According to LexisNexis, defamation is defined as:
“A statement which is untrue and which tends either (a) to lower a person in the estimation of right-thinking members of society generally; or (b) to expose a person to hatred, ridicule or contempt; or (c) to disparage a person in his or her office, profession, calling, trade or business. In order to give rise to liability in tort, the statement must also be published to someone other than the person to whom it relates…”
In simple terms, defamation refers to any statement that harms a person’s reputation. This applies to content posted on social media platforms such as WhatsApp, Facebook, X (formerly Twitter), TikTok, Instagram, and other community forums. If a post is false, harmful, and made with the intent to harm someone’s reputation, the poster (author) may face legal consequences such as civil claims for damages, fines, or even criminal charges.
The High Court has confirmed that online platforms are not exempt from defamation laws. Whether in a newspaper, a public meeting, or a private Facebook group, the same legal principles apply. Private groups offer no legal protection against liability for defamatory statements.
Why This Matters in the Property Industry
Community schemes often face disputes about levies, maintenance, rule enforcement, or service delivery by managing agents. These tensions sometimes lead to frustrated parties turning to social media to publicly criticise trustees, property owners, managing agents, or legal professionals.
However, these public accusations can quickly backfire.
The High Court has found that defamatory content is often shared with the deliberate intention of publicly shaming another person or business, with full awareness of the potential damage it may cause.
In South Africa, defamation on social media can have both civil and criminal consequences, including:
- Legal action against individuals or against the trustees/body corporate as a collective.
- Breakdown of professional relationships.
- Reputational harm to the scheme, potentially lowering property values and deterring investors.
- Trustees breaching fiduciary duties, which can lead to removal from office or personal liability.
When adjudicating defamation cases, South African courts balance Section 10 (human dignity) and Section 16 (freedom of expression) of the Constitution. The outcome depends on whether the statement unlawfully infringes on another’s dignity while weighing the right to express opinions.
How to Prove Online Defamation
Three elements must be present for a successful defamation claim related to social media posts:
- Wrongful Intent
The post must have been made intentionally, with the aim of damaging another person’s dignity or reputation. This satisfies the legal requirement of intention and unlawfulness.
- Publication to a Third Party
The defamatory statement must have been shared on a public platform, such as social media, and read by someone other than the person it’s about, for instance, a Facebook friend who understands the damaging nature of the post.
- Harm to Reputation
The content must be such that a reasonable person would view it as harmful to the subject’s reputation or standing in the community. In other words, it must negatively influence how others perceive the person.
Tips to Avoid Legal Trouble on Social Media
Here’s how to avoid falling foul of defamation laws:
- Choose Direct, Constructive Communication
Before posting online, consider resolving the issue privately through formal meetings, email correspondence, or legal procedures. Clear internal communication channels can prevent unnecessary disputes.
- Respect Privacy and POPIA
Sharing private information or correspondence may breach the Protection of Personal Information Act (POPIA), leading to additional legal action.
- Maintain Professionalism
Whether you’re a trustee, managing agent, or property owner, publicly venting frustrations is not acceptable. Uphold professionalism at all times, even when tensions run high.
- Seek Legal Advice if Unsure
If you’re uncertain whether your statement may be defamatory, consult a legal practitioner or managing agent before posting.
What About Negative Reviews?
A common question arises: Can a bad review be defamatory?
The answer is yes! If the review contains false statements that damage the reputation of a managing agent or trustee. If the review misleads others into thinking poorly of the person or business, it may be considered defamatory.
In conclusion, as recent court rulings have shown, freedom of speech does not protect you from the consequences of defamation. All parties involved in managing community schemes (trustees, managing agents, property owners, and tenants) should strive to foster respectful, lawful communication.
At SBL, we encourage professional engagement and dispute resolution through appropriate legal channels, not social media.
For expert legal advice, dispute resolution assistance, or trustee training, feel free to contact our team. We’re here to help you protect the integrity of your community scheme.
The 2026 CCMA Rule Changes
The 2026 CCMA Rule Changes: What Employers and Employees Need to Know The way workplace disputes are handled in South Africa is changing, and some of these changes may catch employers and employees by surprise. On 23 October 2026, new rules governing proceedings...
Early Cancellation of a Residential Lease: Landlord vs Tenant
Early Cancellation of a Residential Lease: Landlord vs Tenant By Cilna Steyn, Managing Director of SBL Incorporated Early cancellation of a residential lease is often misunderstood, particularly because the rights of a tenant and landlord are not the same. When the...
Neighbour Nightmares
Neighbour Nightmares: When Does an Annoying Neighbour Become a Legal Problem? Most of us expect our homes to be places of comfort, privacy and peace. Unfortunately, that's not always the reality. From persistent noise and barking dogs to boundary disputes, parking...



